Walk into any gym and you’ll see two distinct camps. In one corner, you have the guys maxing out on singles and doubles, veins bulging. In the other, you have the high-rep warriors doing sets of 50 with light weights. But if your goal is pure hypertrophy—building as much muscle as possible—who is right?

Research suggests the answer lies in a specific “Goldilocks” zone that balances mechanical tension, metabolic stress, and fatigue management.

Here’s the breakdown of the science behind how heavy you should actually be lifting to pack on size.

The Problem with Lifting Too Light (Under 30% 1RM)

You might think that as long as you go to failure, any weight will build muscle. While technically true, lifting weights under 30% of your One Rep Max (1RM) is highly inefficient.

• Systemic Fatigue: To get close to failure with light weights (think sets of 50+), you have to perform dozens of “junk reps” before the muscle growth mechanism actually kicks in. This causes massive systemic fatigue without a proportional muscle-building payoff.
• Fiber Conversion: Exclusively training in super-high rep ranges can convert your muscle fibers toward “slow-twitch” characteristics. These fibers generally have less growth potential than their fast-twitch counterparts.
• Inefficiency: You would need to do an absurd number of sets to match the stimulus of a heavier set, wasting valuable time in the gym.

The Problem with Lifting Too Heavy (Over 85% 1RM)

On the flip side, lifting near-maximal weights (85% to 100% of your 1RM) is great for powerlifting strength, but suboptimal for pure size.

• Joint Stress: Consistently grinding out heavy singles and doubles places immense stress on your joints and connective tissues.
• Injury Risk: The closer you get to your max, the higher your risk of injury becomes. A torn pec or a blown-out back will halt your gains faster than any bad program.
• Volume Issues: To get enough volume for growth doing sets of 2 or 3, you would have to be in the gym for hours. It’s simply not time-efficient for hypertrophy.

The Hypertrophy “Sweet Spot”: 5 to 30 Reps

So, if super light is inefficient and super heavy is dangerous, what’s left? Research indicates that spending the majority of your time in the 30% to 85% of 1RM range is optimal for muscle growth.

In practical terms, this translates to sets of roughly 5 to 30 reps, taken close to failure.

This wide range gives you the best of both worlds: enough mechanical tension to stimulate growth, but enough volume to exhaust the muscle fibers without destroying your joints.

Matching Rep Ranges to Exercises

Not all exercises are created equal. Tailoring your rep ranges based on the type of movement yields the best results:

1. The “Anti-Gravity” Compounds (5–15 Reps): For big, compound movements where your body has to stabilize heavy loads against gravity—like Squats, Deadlifts, Bent-Over Rows, and Overhead Presses—stick to the lower end of the hypertrophy range (5 to 15 reps). High-rep squats are effective, but often cardiovascular fatigue or lower back pumps become the limiting factor before your quads actually fail.

2. Machines and Isolations (15–30 Reps): For exercises where stability is provided for you, or the load is lighter—like machine presses, bicep curls, lateral raises, or leg extensions—aim for the higher end (15 to 30 reps). These movements are safer to take to deep failure at higher repetitions without the risk of systemic collapse.

Structuring Your Training: The 50/25/25 Rule

You don’t need to pick just one rep range and stick to it forever. In fact, variety is often better for preventing plateaus. A solid structure for intermediate lifters:

• 50% of your training in the 10–20 rep range. This is the “bread and butter” of bodybuilding training.
• 25% of your training in the heavier 5–10 rep range (mostly your big compound lifts).
• 25% of your training in the lighter 20–30 rep range (mostly isolation movements and burnout sets).

SetsApart helps you track this balance. By logging your hard sets per muscle group, you can see whether you’re hitting adequate volume across different rep ranges. The Volume Per Muscle Group feature gives you visibility into your weekly training distribution.

The Bottom Line

Stop worrying about your 1-rep max if your goal is big muscles. Find the exercises that hit your muscles best, stay within the 5–30 rep range, and focus on progressive overload over time. If a rep range feels stale or your joints start to ache, switch it up based on the 50/25/25 rule.

---

Source

This article was inspired by and summarizes key insights from the following video. Check out the video for more detail and subscribe to the channel—it’s a great resource for evidence-based training.

Watch the full video: How Heavy to Lift for Muscle Growth | Hypertrophy Made Simple #4